Ahead of the implementation of a no-fly zone over Libya, China spent a total of 10 days pulling about 36,000 of its nationals out of the country. It was a quick and effective operation, but some of the details haven’t been widely reported outside China.
Key to China’s success was the assistance it secured from Greece and Malta, which was made possible by the close bilateral relations China has with these two nations. For example, when Greece was engulfed by a financial crisis late last year, China didn’t just stand idly by. Instead, Premier Wen Jiabao visited Greece and publicly declared his support for the country, including offering to buy Greek bonds.
Such diplomacy no doubt made it easier for China to utilize two vessels from Greece to make several trips to transport more than 10,000 Chinese workers during the Libyan pullout. Indeed, when these workers reached Crete, the Greek prime minister welcomed them personally.
China's relations with Malta are also good, helped along by a little personal diplomacy on the part of Chinese President Hu Jintao last year. When Malta’s president had a fall last year during a visit to Shanghai, Hu visited him in hospital before arranging for a new flight, and instructed a Foreign Ministry official to accompany him back to Malta. Maltese President George Abela was said to be extremely grateful to the Chinese government, and Hu personally.
Another interesting incident during the evacuation from Libya came when officials from the Foreign Ministry were waiting at the border between Libya and Tunisia for workers from Chinese companies. An expected group from a company headquartered in Beijing didn’t arrive at the stipulated time, prompting Chinese officials to dispatch a car to find out what was going on. However, the officials were detained at a checkpoint and were asked to prove that the about 3000 workers that were being detained were really Chinese. At this point the detained workers are said to have promptly stood up and to have started singing the Chinese national anthem; checkpoint officials were reportedly so surprised they released the detained workers immediately.
Meanwhile, about 1,300 workers from a Chinese railway construction company were stopped by checkpoint officials as they tried to leave Libya. A Foreign Ministry official is said to have intervened by seeking the help of Libyan police. The police reportedly responded by forming an advance patrol for the more than 40 trucks carrying Chinese workers, allowing the convoy to pass through checkpoints in time to board a plane home.
But China’s assistance extended past its own citizens. Another Chinese company ferried about 900 Bangladeshi, Nepali and Vietnamese workers from Benghazi in Libya to Crete. Initially, the Greek authorities only allowed the Chinese nationals into the country. However, China's Foreign Ministry negotiated with Greek officials and eventually succeeded in persuading Greece to allow the foreign workers in too. These workers subsequently boarded a plane operated by a Chinese airline back to Beijing. Upon reaching Beijing, they were provided with food and accommodation, while Chinese officials worked with the relevant embassies in arranging for connecting flights to their home countries.
All of this highlights three things. The first is that China saw the pullout not just as a national emergency, but also as a valuable learning experience. Second, unity between China's government, ruling party, military and the general public provided a reassuring clarity and focus that bodes well for any similar incidents in the future.
More than anything, though, the efficiency of the pullout from Libya was a genuine foreign policy success, and an example of some nimble Chinese diplomacy.








Suresh Sampath
Thank you for an informative article. Having lived for some time in China and being married to a Chinese I have come to feel that the Chinese are truly brilliant in their understanding of human relationships and how to achieve a very high level of social organization through their managing of these relationships. Just as was in the Three Kingdoms period as today’s international economic and political landscape where the Chinese nation seeks greater and greater influence, the Chinese have shown themselves adept at building and maintaining lasting relationships which they can utilize to accomplish remarkable things.
Mu Chunshan
Dear Suresh
You are right.
As a reporter, I especially compared different Libya evacuation operation among China, France, Britain, Canada, India and other countries the conclusion is Chinese did well.
canrun
I literally did not read the author’s name when I started reading this article. When I finished I said to myself, “that surely was not Jason Miks.”
Much to my surprise, I was…um…actually, I was spot on.
Please fwd. this article to the Global Times. It will fit right in.
Happy every day!
Mu Chunshan
Dear canrun
I just want to introduce more true details about the Chinese evacuation from Libya to the friends outside China, because there are seldom similar articles in western media.
I’m sorry that you think of Global Times when you read it. I hope bystanders should have a little bit sympathy, but not biting irony.
But I have to say that what I told you in the article is the fact. The Chinese government, the ruling party and the ordinary people are really united in this incident.
I interviewed diplomats; employees of Chinese companies, and even Chinese people who are still in Libya at present. Their argument is consistent.
Many Chinese people liken the evacuation as September 11 incident of the United States, because tens of thousands Chinese were danger at that time. I have reported in Chinese media that about 1000 Chinese company employees are forced to flee to desert overnight when Libyan militants attack their camp.
Do you know how ordinary people and families worry about their safe?
Do you know how many request letter did MFA and media received every day?
If you don’t understand the Chinese attitude and mood at that time, please consider the American’s temper, after September 11 attacks.
If you want to search some Chinese irony and criticisms about evacuation, please to see Fa Lun Gong’s media.
canrun
“But I have to say that what I told you in the article is the fact.”
Well, even the Global Times prints facts from time to time.
It is quite apparent that you know full well where your bread is buttered, Mr. Mu, and I do not necessarily disparage you that reality.
Mu Chunshan
If I criticize the Chinese government, can you still say these words? Next time you tell me what you want to hear, I will do it as you hope. HaHa.
Joking apart. My dear, believe it or not, Facts are existence; it will not be obscured by funny bias.
I cherish your comments, but please respect what I contribute.
If you find what matter is wrong, please tell me what is true.
JD
No doubts a master stroke,straight from the “Art of War” by Sun Tzu.
They helped Nepali, Bangladeshi and Vietnamese but why not Pakistanis,their all weather friends(or what ever their relation is)?
Should we say that’s a fair question to both Chinese and Pakistani govts.and for Pakistanis to ponder about their all weather relationship with China?
Mu Chunshan
My Friend, I just give a small example of the evacuation happened in Greek route.
China planned three evacuation routes between Libya and it’s neighbors, Greece is just one of them. There are similar stories in three evacuation routes; I keep much record about stories during independent interview. Maybe in the future I can tell you more.
Yes, China helped Bangladesh to evacuate, but it does not mean that China did not help Pakistan.
From the article, you suppose the relationship between China and Pakistan met problems? I feel puzzled.
I can say the relationship is very good. For example, On March 5 to 30, the two countries hold joint air force training in Pakistan; China sold to Pakistan ZDK-03 early warning aircraft.
JD
Fair enough Mu.It is just that I felt maybe China feels it needs to cultivate these countries more than Pakistan
Mu Chunshan
Anyway, China does not abandon Pakistan, just like the U.S. can’t abandon India.
guest
Chinese withdraw was proof that the dragon is all bark and no bite. You couldn’t even stop the fighting in Libya. If you had balls, you could of assisted the rebels and overthrow Gaddafy as payback for his insults against China.
Mu Chunshan
HaHa, if China did as what you said. It isn’t China.
Matt C
Surely the first example of China relpicating the US international approach. Slowly slowly…
Mu Chunshan
It’s in the national interest of the huge dragon.
John
Mu Chunshan wrote: “It’s in the national interest of the huge dragon.”
This comment interests me.
Can you give me examples whereby Chinese actions were carried out with no benefit to China? Totally altruistic actions.
I am curious as we never really get notified too much when they do it. I would be interested in reading up on those cases.
Thank you.
Mu Chunshan
Dear John
For any country, it seems no totally altruistic actions to do.
But I guess what China want is to make win-win situation in international community.
Traditional oriental philosophy is not to bother anyone; the premise is anyone not to provoke me.
Frank
“Chinese actions were carried out with no benefit to China?”
Why should they?
John
Frank wrote: “Chinese actions were carried out with no benefit to China?”
“Why should they?”
Just as you as a person sometimes does something for someone with no benefit to yourself, its nice when a country does it as well.
People can sometimes misunderstand your actions and ascribe motive to them that is not altruistic, but that does not mean you did something so it benefits you.
Think of how you sometimes give money to a poor person to help them out, you will never see them again, you dont tell anyone you did it, but you did it. True altruistic behavior.
Plus Frank if a nation does something that builds its soft power like helping earthquake victims and then boasts about it and says you should respect me at the very least for helping them, it loses all value. Actions without any intentional benefit to China, can still cause people to like China even if that isn’t the reason China did it.
Though, maybe you are Chinese and feel similar to a Korean woman I once knew who said “why would you be friends with someone if they dont have anything you can get from them”. It seemed a shallow attitude to have but maybe its just a North East Asian attitude, I dont know.
davida
Can u privide an example of any of those western democratic liberal nations, which in ur opinion, are genuine humanitarians, doing good deeds for no “apparent” benifits? Even more outrageous is ur attempt to attribute the materialistic attitude of one chick, who u probably picked up in a bar, to the traits of a race or mentality of a nation. Its like u assume all white guys are homos after u saw a weirdo on a street.
Having said that, whats wrong with a nation pursuing a policy that best serves its interest? Be it helping victims in natrual disasters, assisting refugees fleeing war torn nations or just making donations to those less fortunate in general. Dont tell me that there is no hidden motive behind those generous gestures if u dig deep enough.
Speaking of humanitarians, I am sure that u praise spielberg for not participating in the choregraphic design of beijing olympics openning ceremony after his request to chinese chairman to stop darfu massacre in sudan was turned down. That sounds incredible because china indeed had a lot of influence with sudan goverment back then ( they still do) and could have stopped the killings should they wish to. But there is a twist. Why didnt he make a request to us president to alleviate the sufferings of palestinians at very hands of his jewish holocaust survivors, whose plight in ww2 was brought to life in his epic ” schindler list”. Yet, unlike some other directors, even israli ones, he didnt make one movie about or even pay the lip service to the dire situation in the palestinians refugee camp or on the land under his own people illegitimate occupation. ( which was officially declared by un under the resolution and only us vetoed it).
So whats with the hyspocrisy and double standards? So if there is a true humanitarian, who is truly sent by the almighty to save humanity, then the pope in the vatican city must be the candidate no.1. Oh, hold that thought. If u do enough research, u will find to ur astonishment that Catholic churches are, if anything, more of well orgnised business entity than a charity orgnisation, whose goal to convince people of their spiritual faith and in doing so, live well off their donations. The pope might be holy in spirit, but he and his massive entourage are in fresh and blood who need to survive physically first in order to convey god’s messages to the faithfuls. How else, based on the latest audit of roman churches, would the world see their business tenacles stretch into banking, stockexchange, real estate and other industries.( arent they supposed to give back all they have taken? because after all they are churches for christ sake)
So if the pope isnt qualified to be a true humanitarian, i doubt who else is, oh maybe my standards are too high. Or Are they?
EAM
Kudos to the Chinese in delivering a succesful resucue operation. I am not sure about the carping about GT. It is a quality newspaper and provides a valuable insight into the Chinese view of the world. Certainly, much better than Fox News.
Mu Chunshan
HaHa, actually sometimes I contribute to GT, just like I send entries to the Diplomat.
There are multiple-voices in GT in which editors are not nationalists, but the GUV seems willing to be seen as it.
Yuhao
Surprised by the paragraph on “3000 workers singing the Chinese national anthem” I googled a bit, as I’ve never heard of it (And the propaganda machine didn’t mentioned it either). It did appear on some chinese websites, but those are basically online forums and this fact was quickly identified as fake.
Mu Chunshan
My dear
Is it astonishing to you? Right, when I heard of it, I have the same feeling.
As I said in other comments, I just want to introduce more true details about the Chinese evacuation from Libya to the friends outside China, because there are seldom similar articles in western media. Many of it is what I interview form Chinese labor and diplomats in Libya.
there is no way to explain if you think it is fake, unless Chinese labor and diplomats cheat me. HaHa.
By the way, Google is not everything. Forum is not nothing.